The hunt for unknown life in New York City

The globe is full of unknown species. But is it really possible to find a completely new animal species in the middle of the largest city in the United States?

“People like to imagine that undiscovered species are only found in remote rainforests or the great ocean depths, but they can be found everywhere. Even in areas that are well studied, we continue to discover species that are new to science,” says Emily Hartop.

Hartop is an entomologist at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology’s natural history museum in Trondheim, the NTNU University Museum.

She is collaborating with multiple research partners—the American media outlet Vox, the Centre for Biodiversity Genomics at the University of Guelph in Canada, and the Prospect Park Alliance and Central Park Conservancy in New York—in the hunt for unknown life in the largest city in the United States. She feels confident that they will find something.

“It’s highly likely. In my field, discovering new species is the rule rather than the exception,” Hartop says.

Most animal species are unknown

“The reality is that the majority of Earth’s animal species are still unknown to us humans. Scientists have formally named around 2 million species, but the actual number of species is perhaps 10 times higher,” Hartop says.

You may have already guessed that Hartop isn’t looking for unknown bear or gorilla species. We have—unfortunately, some might say—a pretty good grasp of them. Insects, on the other hand, constitute a large blank spot on the species map, especially those within the category of “dark taxa”—groups of organisms that are extremely species-rich but about which we know very little.

“A lot of dark taxa are small insects, mites and other organisms that receive little attention compared with more charismatic groups like mammals and bees. They are often both common and ecologically important, but we simply don’t have enough specialists to get an overview of them.”

You may be wondering how you can even begin to find unknown insects in the middle of a city. Well, it happens in several stages.

Step 1: Collecting insects

The hunt for unknown life in New York is being carried out by setting up tentlike insect traps—called Malaise traps—two of which have now been placed in Central Park and Prospect Park. Both are highly urban parks located in Manhattan and Brooklyn, respectively. The traps work by guiding insects into a container of ethanol, where they are killed and preserved.

Step 2: DNA sequencing

Once a month, the collected insects are sent to the Centre for Biodiversity Genomics (CBG) in Canada. There, the genetic material of the insects in the traps is mapped using a method called DNA barcoding. The method works by using a short, defined part of the genetic material—the DNA—to act as a genetic barcode for each species. In the same way that an item in a store has a unique barcode, species can be identified through their DNA barcode.

The DNA barcodes of the species in the traps are then compared with a large reference library. If there are no matches in the library—that is, no registered species sharing the same DNA barcode—this may indicate that something new has been found.

Step 3: Send in the experts

Insects that show up with a unique DNA barcode are sent to researchers in the respective species groups. They conduct further investigations to find out if they are new species. One of these researchers is Hartop at the NTNU University Museum. She is a global expert on humpbacked flies, a highly species-rich family of small flies.

Step 4: The new species gets a name

If something new is found, the species will be described scientifically and given a name—a laborious process that can often take a couple of years.

You could have unknown life in your garden

“One of the most exciting things about this project is that it challenges the idea that new discoveries only happen in remote wilderness areas. The truth is that unknown species can be discovered in parks and gardens too,” Hartop says.

She says it’s very likely that we would find something new if we followed the same procedures in Trondheim or almost any other city.

Flies are amazing

This enormous number of unknown insects helps keep the ecological balance on the planet from collapsing. It might be worth reminding yourself of this—even if you never quite experience Hartop’s love for flies.

“People often ask me why I study small flies. The truth is, flies are amazing. They are among the most diverse organisms on the planet, they’ve evolved an incredible variety of lifestyles, and a lot of them are genuinely beautiful,” Hartop says.

“Every time we look closely, flies remind us that the living world is far more diverse, fascinating and mysterious than we imagine it.”

Who’s behind this story?

Swati Mestri

Swati Mestri holds a bachelor’s degree in Electronics Engineering and has worked as a content editor since 2019. She has experience editing research documents across technology, health care, and materials science, and has a particular interest in technology and space.

Full profile →

Andrew Zinin

Master’s in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X’s editorial success.

Full profile →